Real Food Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie

December 23rd, 2013 | Posted by Alison Spath in Short or Sweet

This recipe is not healthy.  Not at all.

Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie Slice

But ’tis the season to make your kids the sweet foods that they’re asking for, so I’m singing “Fa la la la la, LA LA LA LA!” with my fingers in my ears when it comes to sugar consumption right now.

OK, OK… <insert fake, dramatic eye roll here> I guess I can make Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie.  Twist my arm whydontcha.

When I went searching the web for a clue on how to make Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie, more than one recipe called for Cool Whip and Oreo’s.  (Head –> Desk)  Given that these are two of the worst foods we could possibly eat, (Oreos can be compared to crack and Cool Whip is made with both high fructose corn syrup and hydrogenated vegetable oil and is not fit for human consumption – but this post isn’t supposed to be a downer so I’ll shut up now) I was determined to figure out the real food alternative to Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie and spare us from those two frankenfood superstars.  Fillers and artificial ingredients scare way me more than sugar.  Let’s do this.

Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie

print this recipe!

Chocolate Graham Cracker Crust

6 Tbsp butter, melted
1/4 cup brown sugar
1 (7oz) bag Newman’s Chocolate Alphabet Cookies*

Crumble cookies in food processor or blender (or even by hand with a large zip lock bag, a towel and a hammer!)

It was at this point that Zak said, “I can tell this is going to be good.”

Cookie Crust Ingredients

Mix cookies, sugar and butter and press the into a pie pan.  Chill while preparing the filling.

Chocolate Cookie Crust

*Newman’s Own Alphabet Cookies are probably a stretch when it comes to “real food”, but the ingredient list was shorter and better than the graham crackers I considered that were also on the shelf at my natural food store.

Peanut Butter Pie Filling

1 c heavy whipping cream
1 c creamy organic peanut butter
1 (8 oz) package of organic cream cheese
1 c powdered sugar

Whip cream to stiff peaks.  In a separate bowl, beat softened cream cheese, sugar and peanut butter until smooth, then gently fold in whipped cream.  Pour mixture into crust, chill for two hours before serving.  Top with shaved chocolate or pipe on melted chocolate.

Suddenly I’m thinking about that song “Happy Together” by The Turtles.

Peanut Butter Filling

If I should call you up, invest a dime, and you say you belong to me, and ease my mind –

Crust and Filling

imagine how the world could be, so very fine…

Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie


Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie

Cue “Deck the Halls”, fingers in ears, “Fa la la la! La la LA LAAAA!”

This pie was seriously delicious, I have to admit it.  The good news?  It is VERY rich, one small piece is plenty!

The bad news?  It is VERY rich, one small piece is plenty.  This means the leftovers from our holiday gathering this weekend just keep hanging on.

Slice of Peanut Butter Pie

Apparently Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie comes with a soundtrack because I’ll be singing “You Keep Me Hanging On” by the Supreme’s until somebody else eats the last piece and it’s out of my fridge.

Real butter, real cream cheese, heavy whipping cream.  Now you’re singing my tune.

Happy holidays to you and yours!  Eat well, be merry and give thanks that calories don’t count the week between Christmas and New Years.**

**The fourth song on the Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie soundtrack is “Would I Lie to You?” by The Eurythmics.

Please know that links to Amazon are affiliate links. It doesn’t change the price you pay, but if you buy something from Amazon after following one of the links in my posts, I earn a percentage based commission from Amazon as a part of their affiliate program. This is one of the ways I generate revenue from the posts that I write here. I promise that I only link to items that I truly endorse. You don’t ever have to buy anything, but if you do, thank you for supporting the site and the work I do here.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 Both comments and pings are currently closed.

5 Responses

  • sarah says:

    OK, I realize this is super-high maintenance of me, but could you invent a version in which the predominant thing is chocolate, and the accent is PB? oh, what am I thinking. I’m the only one in the house who could eat this – Best Beloved has a serious PB aversion and can’t tolerate chocolate very well. MORE FOR ME! Merry Christmas!

    • I’m going to do exactly this! I need to make another dessert for a party tomorrow and was going to tweak this recipe to make it a little less rich… I’m still going to do that, but now I’m going do a Sarah-inspired inverse of this pie! I’ll let you know how it turns out. 😉

  • zak says:

    This pie is the yummiest thing ever made in our kitchen!

  • Courtney says:

    Thanks for this recipe. We made it for Christmas and it was delicious. It’s the perfect compliment for my pb loving husband and my love for chocolate. But it was hard for me to not add chocolate chips to the filling!!! Maybe next time.